About Algoma Hardware

We are 100% Fishing with a little of everything else!

513 4th St, Algoma, WI 54201

Sunday – Thursday : 8am – 6:30pm

Friday & Saturday : 8am – 7:30pm

Our Story

In 1985 Al Batten father to Kathy Haegele and grandfather to Courtney Villers bought his second hardware, store located in Algoma, WI. His store was mostly hardware with some fishing. Five years later his daughter Kathy bought the store from him. Over the years, with the help of her husband Jerry and son Courtney, she grew the business into a fishing shop, with a little bit of everything.

Today we are still growing. We are a family owned and operated establishment. Every year we add more fishing gear of all kinds. Remodeling to make room for more fishing gear has become a yearly activity and we do not plan to stop. We imagine that someday our 5200 square foot sales floor will just be too small and we will have to find more space. We love working with those who fish and will always strive to continue running a retail location that is open to the public. We never intend to close our doors becoming an “online retailer”.

When it comes to fishing, we have two mindsets:

First carry more lures than anyone else. Though there MAY be some stores in this world with more lures than us, someday they too will be awed by our selection. It makes our day when every day someone new says “Wow you have too many lures”.

Second carry every color of the lures we do. We don’t like leaving a Fishing Person of luck. We don’t like carrying just popular colors. We want everyone to find that rare color they are looking for.
Our second goal becomes quite clear when viewing our Moonshine Lures selection, Pro King selection, and our Complete Acme Kastmaster Selection. That said it can take us a few years to get there which is why our wall of Michigan Stingers is only around half done and our Wall of Swedish Pimples is only about three quarters of the way done.

After 35 years we have met a lot of people and helped a lot of people enjoy fishing. With the opening of our website we are looking forward to another 35 years and beyond!

RODS & REELS

Check out our selection of rods, reels, and more!

Sink your teeth into our selection of terminal tackle.

Hooks, sinkers, floaters and more.

ALSO AVAILABLE IN-STORE!
Browse our hardware.

Nuts, bolts, locks, and other tools.

ALSO AVAILABLE IN-STORE!

Latest News & Deals

No Results Found

The page you requested could not be found. Try refining your search, or use the navigation above to locate the post.

Our Mission & Values

Stock

Though there MAY be some stores in this world with more lures than us, someday they too will be awed by our selection. It makes our day when every day someone new says “Wow you have too many lures”.

Variety

We don’t like leaving a Fishing Person of luck. We don’t like carrying just popular colors. We want everyone to find that rare color they are looking for.

Family Owned

We are a family owned and operated establishment since 1985.  We love working with those who fish and will always strive to continue running a retail location that is open to the public

What They Say

“A very unique experience I find nice unusual things there all the time for fishing and more nice people.”

Marjorie Charlier

“I love (and miss) small hardware stores like this. A real treat to just be in the place. Friendly as well..”

Eric Westland

“Very good selection of fishing gear and knowledgeable staff.”

Seth Uecker

“GREAT SELECTION”

Earl Ruffner

Marjorie Charlier

Eric Westland

Seth Uecker

Earl Ruffner

Follow
Hours

Sunday – Thursday : 8am – 6:30pm

Friday & Saturday : 8am – 7:30pm

CONTACT US

X